Indigenous vs Western Entrepreneurship and why it matters
To understand why there are differences between Indigenous and Western Entrepreneurship and why it’s important, we need to understand that Indigenous people operate(d) differently from Western societies.
Social norms are basically informal rules that govern behavior in societies which includes beliefs, attitudes, and behavior that are considered acceptable in a social group or culture.
For Indigenous people in Australia, it guides how we look and interact in the world (way of being – our customs, tradition, law, and spiritual beliefs).
I haven’t found a good comparison in Australia yet (let me know if you have so I can update) but Indigenous Works (renamed from the Aboriginal Human Resource Council from Canada) provides a great comparison table of the differences between Aboriginal culture and Western culture.
A key thing to note is that while it’s from Canada, First Nations people around the world have social norm similarities with “Community” being the foremost of all values while Western society prioritises “Individualism” as the foremost value.
This affects (for better or worse) how businesses operate in Australia and Western nations – with the best interest of the individual (in most cases) taking priority over the best interest of our community.
We’ve seen this played out in Australia where mining business interests (profit) take priority over the (First Nations) community and even in Brazil – from Rio Tinto blowing up 46,000-year-old culturally significant rock shelters to Brazil’s Government trying to legalise crimes against Indigenous people to progress deforestation and commercial interests.
Because Western social norms influence/control how we operate in Australia, we’ve probably seen how some First Nations people have put their own interests (Western Entrepreneurship) ahead of the community’s best interests.
I’ve seen this in my own community where some self-proclaimed leaders/elders have put their own self-interests ahead of their community. Instead of hiring the best person for the CEO position at our local Aboriginal land council, they voted against the best person getting the job. The reason behind their decision was based on wanting their own family member to get the position despite that person lacking any relevant job experience and know-how.
This is why we believe First Nations Entrepreneurship can change the world for the better.
Social entrepreneurship and corporate responsibility haven’t been around for long despite the promising progress. Take for example the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission which is the regulatory authority for charities and not-for-profit organisations in Australia that was only established/founded in 2012.
First Nations (or Indigenous) Entrepreneurship has been around for millennials, which can provide a framework and way of doing that actually makes a difference in the world instead of the tokenistic gestures and public relations stunts that deliver little to no real long term value to our communities and the world.
After initial consultation from the Barayamal community (Indigenous entrepreneurs and community members) we’ve developed a comparison table below that displays the differences between Indigenous and Western Entrepreneurship based on the cultural differences (social norms) and our own lived experiences – from my own experience of growing up within the Aboriginal community in Gunnedah to working and collaborating with hundreds of Indigenous entrepreneurs and community organisations throughout Australia. In addition, another resource we’ve developed is the Barayamal Community Agreement which provides a framework that will allow First Nations businesses to measure their contributions to community (in-kind and cash).
I believe that our resources are a good starting point to help differentiate and showcase Indigenous Entrepreneurship to the world, however, we’ll continue to update and publish more resources as we progress – any feedback is appreciated to help us improve things.
Let’s make our ancestors proud and build sustainable businesses that have a positive impact on our communities.
P.S. The featured article image is my own artwork which symbolises the strong backbone/spine of the black swan and First Nations people/entrepreneurs. Courage is required to speak out against the tokenistic policies and inequality – unfortunately, a continuing reality across Australia and not just for First Nations people. This truth-telling is inherently regarded by the power brokers (I refer to them as the “Indigenous Wealth Managers”) as disruptive, and undesirable but we’ll continue to stay strong and respectively fight for a better world for everyone through Indigenous Entrepreneurship.